
An insurance company that pays full workers’ compensation to an injured insured employee who has more than one employer is entitled to receive compensation for the share provided on behalf of the other employer.
However, a workers’ compensation insurer must specifically notify New Hampshire’s Second Injury Special Fund within 100 weeks of a worker’s injury if it has a potential claim against the fund, the state Supreme Court ruled.
The Supreme Court upheld the state Department of Labor in denying the claim of insurer EBIS Inc., which sought compensation from the state’s own fund after it paid full benefits on behalf of the injured worker at its insurer, BAE Systems, Inc., because the BAE worker also worked for another company.
Under state law, when an employee has more than one employer, the employer and the insurance company where the employee was injured are primarily responsible for paying all benefits. Any additional compensation due to the employee’s concurrent employment will be paid by the Special Fund if claimed within 100 weeks of the injury.
In the case before the court, EBIS did not bring its claim against the fund until 29 August 2022, more than 100 weeks after 7 January 2020, when the BAE employee sustained her injury. The insurer argued that the pay memos it submitted in 2020 and 2022 to the Department of Labor (DOL), which administers the private fund, served as notice of its potential claim against the fund, specifically because two of the memos contained handwritten notes that the employee’s average weekly pay was based on her combined pay from BAE and another employer.
Initially, the Department of Labor denied the second EBIS injury claim because it found that the 100-week deadline had passed. The Fund concluded that the notes were insufficient to notify it of the insurer’s potential claim. The Fund confirmed that the memos “only relate to the insurance company’s obligations to pay compensation to the injured worker, without referring to the claim against the Special Injuries Fund.” “There is also nothing in the payment notes to indicate a potential claim against the Special Injuries Fund,” the fund coordinator explained.
EBIS appealed and the Compensation Appeals Board (CAB) reversed its decision, finding that EBIS had met the notice requirements with its notes on its payments. The CAB noted that it “should be presumed” that the DOL employee who received the pay memos “knew or should have known that the double memos were being submitted for the purposes of such a claim even if he did not work directly in the Second Injury Fund Division.” The Supreme Court noted that the CAB did not cite any legal or factual basis for the presumption behind its decision.
The Ministry of Labor appealed this reversal of its denial.
The Supreme Court has now agreed with the Department of Labor that the insurer’s pay memos only notified the Department of Labor that the employee had received workers’ compensation benefits in accordance with the law and did not provide notice that the insurer intended to file a “potential claim” against the fund.
“We are not persuaded that the briefs satisfy the statutory notice requirements. The law places the burden on the employer or carrier to notify the commissioner that it may have a claim against the fund. The Supreme Court concluded that the commissioner is not required to attempt to infer from filings made for other purposes that the employer or carrier may seek reimbursement from the fund.”
Topics
Transportation companies
Interested in? Transportation companies?
Get automatic alerts for this topic.
